I was sitting in a coffee shop recently with a young woman who described herself as a Taoist Pagan Pantheist. My first thought was, “what the heck is that?” Luckily what came out of my mouth was slightly more tactful, “describe that for me, I’ve never met someone who described herself that way” (Translation: what the heck is that!).
After we talked for a while, she recommended I read this book. So here’s my synopsis – pretty fascinating book, actually. I’m looking forward to getting together with her again to discuss it.
The Tao of Pooh was a very enlightening book. Besides just giving a very simple and entertaining explanation of the essence of Taoism (through the eyes of that crazy little bear), this book challenged modernist assumptions on many levels and in some ways was very refreshing.
From the Taoist point of view, while the scholarly intellect may be useful for analyzing certain things, deeper and broader matters are beyond its limited reach (24)…and one sometimes gets the impression that those intimidating words are there to keep us from understanding. That way the scholars can appear Superior, and will not likely be suspected of Not Knowing Something (28).
But sometimes the knowledge of the scholar is a bit hard to understand because it doesn’t seem to match up with our own experience of things. In other words, Knowledge and Experience do not necessarily speak the same language. But isn’t the knowledge that comes from experience more valuable than the knowledge that doesn’t? (28-9)
Now, scholars can be very useful and necessary, in their own dull and unamusing way. They provide a lot of information. It’s just that there is Something More, and that Something More is what life is really about (31).
My only critique of the book is that it is purely theoretical. In some ways it does the very thing it critiques – only exists in the abstract area of the mind – there is nothing practical. It left me wondering what Taoism looks like in the life of a real person. What would it look like in my life? How does it transform my relationships? How does it connect me to something bigger than myself? How does it lead me to change the world? How does it encourage me to pour myself into community or the lives of other people? How does it help me change the shit of my life or heal my brokenness?
This is the first book I’ve read on Taoism and so I don’t know whether there is something out there that addresses some of my questions or not. I don’t know whether there is a more concrete story of the life of a Taoist or not (if someone knows of one, I’d love to read it – something similar to Blue Like Jazz?). In fact, this book leaves me wondering whether Taoism has anything to offer me other than some good, abstract ideas to think about. At the same time, I want to avoid being too critical and demanding of a book that isn’t meant to be exhaustive about its subject.
May 2, 2007 at 10:39 pm
In my experience, knowledge of the tao has been highly beneficial i my approaches to everyday challenges.
the abstract manner in which it is taught is an eastern method of teaching.
in the east a good teacher isnt someone who can exaplain something clearly to you. a good teacher is someone who can guide you through to work something out for yourself.
im no expert on Taoism but am getting more and more interested in it recently.
i recommend checking out some alan watts to learn more about the concept in a clear manner.
i link to a torrent on my blog that has some good stuff
http://shadowsbeneathleaves.blogspot.com/2007/05/taoism.html
May 3, 2007 at 7:53 am
Dave,
Thanks for your comment and your suggestion. I will check out those resources sometime soon.
July 10, 2007 at 3:13 pm
Your friendly neighborhood Taoist Pagan Pantheist here, finding all sorts of ways to procrastinate on my schoolwork. Imagine my surprise to find your book review while exploring Suther Land! I’m mighty impressed that you 1) read it; and 2) took the time to think it through critically and post about it. And, I appreciate your tact – something I promise to work on myself
I think your criticism is valid; the abstract nature of Taoism (and Buddhism, for that matter) presents a challenge. The fact that Taoism is part of a lyrical mystical tradition makes it hard for me – a more linear, logical thinker – to wrap my head around the philosophy sometimes. And maybe that’s not the point…at some level, it just *feels* right to me.
One of the things I like in the Tao of Pooh is Hoff’s critique of our society as being chronically busy (though I think this cultural trait is much less prevalent in a place like Missoula). We’re constantly on the go, or distracting ourselves by watching television, shopping, drinking, taking drugs, etc. America values productivity much more than reflection, or stillness.
“Say, Pooh, why aren’t you busy?” I said.
“Because it’s a nice day,” said Pooh.
“Yes but —”
“Why ruin it?” he said.
“But you could be doing something Important,” I said.
“I am,” said Pooh.
“Oh? Doing what?”
“Listening,” he said.
“Listening to what?”
“To the birds. And that squirrel over there.”
Good ol’ Pooh! I also love the stories about people trying to buy Happiness and Importance at the store. And the encouragement to listen to our intuition and respect our inner nature – to stop trying to jam square pegs into round holes.
What does this all look like in real life? Well, like Dave, I’m no expert in Taoism. But I can tell you what it looks like in my life.
- making time for meditation
- working to reduce my personal consumption – recognizing what is extraneous, and what emotional/social needs I’m trying to fulfill by buying something
- respecting and honoring both the cycles of nature as well as my own personal rhythms
- striving (key word here!) to meet aggression with patience, understanding and compassion, rather than with more aggression
- striving (again!) to be present and appreciative of what is
- striving to act out of joy and love rather than out of fear, guilt, jealousy, or anger
- recognizing that an inner cultivation of character will allow me to bring my gifts and my best self into the community
So that’s the tip of the iceberg, and maybe not so different from what it looks like to live a life devoted to God – ??
In my mind, ecopsychology (my grad program) is really just ancient spiritual wisdom repackaged and sold as science. Same mountain, many different paths. And maybe some of the things I think of as Taoist philosophy are actually more like Jungian psychology, or Buddhism. I haven’t come up with a good label for my personal spiritual philosophy – hence the clunky description in your first sentence! We all find a particulary brand of spirituality that feels like the right fit for us, so I suppose if mine doesn’t easily slot into a pre-existing category, well, that’s okay.
I look forward to getting together and talking more!
May 22, 2008 at 11:02 am
Lovely post.
P.S. There are quite a few of us
It is a philosophy that fits well with earthwise practice.
Sia